March 4, 2013
Like Smith’s The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight (2012), this sweet novel has a premise worthy of the movies. When a lonely teenage Hollywood heartthrob accidentally e-mails a 16-year-old girl in smalltown Maine, there is an immediate spark. Graham arranges to shoot his new movie in Ellie’s seaside town, surprising her with his true identity and leaving levelheaded Ellie feeling “wildly unbalanced.” This is partly due to Graham’s fame, but also because she fears the spotlight would expose a family secret. The cute, brief e-mails between Ellie and Graham showcase the rapid but authentic connection between them (putting aside that they would be far more likely to text each other in this situation). Because the book is told from both characters’ perspectives, readers will understand their vulnerabilities as they try to take their relationship into the real world. Ellie’s family secret may not seem severe enough for the consternation it creates, and readers may be exasperated by the dramas that keep the couple apart. However, the charming leads, smalltown backdrop, and absurdly romantic conceit will win hearts. Ages 15–up. Agent: Jennifer Joel, ICM.
May 1, 2013
Gr 8 Up-This well-crafted, character-driven love story opens with an endearing prologue told in emails. When 16-year-old Ellie O'Neill accidentally starts an exchange with a stranger, she doesn't expect their virtual conversations to turn into a romance. But over the course of a few months, that's exactly what happens. Ellie doesn't know the boy's name until he shows up on her doorstep. He's Graham Larkin, a famous movie star whose next film just happens to be shooting in her quiet Maine town. While most of the girls are dying to be in her shoes, she has reservations. Ellie is the illegitimate daughter of a prominent politician, and her mom moved them to escape the unrelenting media. Now they struggle financially in order to maintain their privacy. Graham's life is anything but private. However, though he is handsome and wealthy, the teen is also lonely and uninspired. His parents, uncomfortable with his fame, choose to distance themselves from him, while his controlling manager wants Graham to date his beautiful costar for the good publicity. Despite those obstacles, Ellie and Graham sustain a sweet and genuine romance. Their chemistry is undeniable, and readers will wonder about their love story long after the last page. An excellent recommendation for fans of Maureen Johnson.-Kimberly Garnick Giarratano, Rockaway Township Public Library, NJ
Copyright 2013 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
March 1, 2013
A typo misdirects teen film star Graham's email to Ellie in Henley, Maine, launching an intense epistolary friendship that rapidly becomes an anchor for each. Keeping his identity secret from Ellie frees Graham to be the pre-celebrity self he's felt disappearing. Anonymity allows Ellie to safely share private dreams and worries (like how to pay for the prestigious but expensive Harvard poetry workshop that's accepted her), though not the secrets her family life rests on. Spending his star capital recklessly, Graham insists on Henley as a film location. Their relationship intensifies when they meet in person. Confident yet lonely, Graham pursues more-conflicted Ellie. For Graham--isolated by fame, adrift in a world where image trumps authenticity--Ellie's a lifeline connecting him to what's real. But as their attraction grows, so does the threat his fame poses to Ellie, tasked with protecting family secrets. Utterly convincing, Graham and Ellie lend credibility to the otherwise far-fetched setup. Smith's work, occupying the zone between literary and commercial fiction, occasionally has an airbrushed feel, avoiding life's messier realities. (Graham and Ellie's chaste behavior seems at odds with their passionate longing, for instance.) It's a minor quibble, though, next to the author's strong suit: a cast of vivid, sympathetic characters whose fate matters to readers and keeps them turning the pages. (Fiction. 13 & up)
COPYRIGHT(2013) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
April 1, 2013
Grades 8-11 When GDL gets an e-mail address wrong, the surprise recipient, EONeill, decides to reply. The two develop a deep and intimate rapport despite guarding their true identities. But down-to-earth movie star Graham Larkin is certain that Ellie is someone special, and he lobbies to shoot his new movie in the middle of nowhere, Maine, Ellie's hometown. Ellie is shocked to learn who Graham is, and she is anything but thrilled by the prospect of dating a teen heartthrob. Meanwhile, the paparazzi trailing Graham threaten to upturn the quiet, carefully constructed life Ellie and her mother have nurtured to smooth over a high-profile secret. The shared third-person narration lends a quiet insight into these two likable characters whose histories and flaws are relatable and fully fleshed out. The blend of celebrity glitz and small-town coziness gives this summer love story a pleasant frame, and it will leave readers wishing for more time with this endearing couple as the sun rises on their last morning together.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2013, American Library Association.)
May 1, 2013
When sixteen-year-old Ellie erroneously receives an email from GDL824@yahoo.com, she writes back, striking up a snappy, flirtatious friendship with the stranger. Thankfully, this isn't a cautionary tale about an internet predator, though GDL has omitted crucial information: he's actually Graham Larkin, one of the hottest teen movie stars in the country. And, in part because of their friendship, he's decided to spend the summer filming in Ellie's small town of Henley, Maine. Ellie and Graham feel an instant attraction: after all, they already know each other. But their relationship faces challenges and disapproval from both sides. Graham is encouraged to date an actress and is relentlessly pursued by paparazzi; Ellie, hiding a family secret, doesn't want to be photographed with him or reveal their relationship to her mother. This wish-fulfillment fantasy (who wouldn't want to be secretly corresponding with a celebrity who's both gorgeous and normal?) features likable protagonists who have undeniable chemistry. Told from both Graham's and Ellie's perspectives, the thoughtful narration is slow and unhurried, just like its sleepy small-town setting. Both characters are given time to grow and bring out the best in each other, and Ellie and Graham's connection, "like the pull of a magnet, powerful and inevitable," lingers on beyond their wistful but optimistic goodbye. rachel l. smith
(Copyright 2013 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)
July 1, 2013
When sixteen-year-old Ellie erroneously receives an email from GDL824@yahoo.com, she strikes up a flirtatious friendship with the stranger: he's actually Graham Larkin, one of the hottest teen movie stars in the country. Told from both Graham's and Ellie's perspectives, this wish-fulfillment fantasy (who wouldn't want to be secretly corresponding with a celebrity who's both gorgeous and normal?) features likable protagonists who have undeniable chemistry.
(Copyright 2013 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)